When a right-of-way boat changes course, her obligation to give a keep-clear boat room to keep clear under rule 16.1 begins. The right-of-way boat may give that room by making an additional change of course. If, while the right-of-way boat is making that additional change of course, the keep-clear boat unavoidably breaks a rule of Part 2 Section A, the keep-clear boat is exonerated by rule 43.1(b).
Facts and Protest Committee Decision
At position 1, three J/105s, S, PA and PB, were racing upwind, with S on starboard tack and PA and PB on port tack. At position 2, S bore away to avoid contact with PA. PA took a penalty.
When S luffed after avoiding PA, she was on a collision course with PB (position 3). Due to the proximity of the boats, PB was unable to keep clear of S either by tacking or by maintaining her course. S promptly bore away to avoid contact and hailed “Protest!”
The protest committee disqualified PB for breaking rule 10. PB appealed.
Decision At position 2, S could continue to sail the course she was sailing with no need to take action to avoid PB; therefore PB was keeping clear (see the definition Keep Clear). At position 3, after S luffed, the boats were on collision courses, and PB was unable to keep clear of S either by tacking or maintaining her course. S needed to change course to avoid contact with PB.
When S, the right-of-way boat, changed course between positions 2 and 3, rule 16.1 required her to give PB room to keep clear. By promptly bearing away and avoiding PB, S complied with her obligation to give PB room.
Because S needed to change course to avoid PB, PB broke rule 10. However, she is exonerated for that breach by rule 43.1(b) because she was sailing within the room to which she was entitled under rule 16.1. PB’s appeal is upheld and she is to be reinstated.
See also Case 146.
USSA 2019/120
Last Updated
Rules
Racing Rules of Sailing for 2013-2016; Version 6
December 2015
Racing Rules of Sailing for 2017-2020
August 2017
Racing Rules of Sailing for 2021-2024
December 2020
Prescriptions
Australia
July 2017
Canada
November 2019
Great Britain - RYA has declined to grant a license for prescriptions and cases.
November 2019
New Zealand
July 2017
United States
February 2017
Cases
World Sailing Cases
February 2022
World Sailing Q&As
March 2022
Match Race Calls
January 2020
Match Race Rapid Response Calls
October 2018
Team Race Calls
December 2018
Team Race Rapid Response Calls
February 2016
CAN Cases
October 2017
RYA Cases
November 2019
US Appeals
November 2019
Manuals
World Sailing Judges Manual
December 2019
Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn more