Skip to main content

The Racing Rules of Sailing

RRS 60.2(a)(1) "...conspicuously display a red flag...

Unsubscribe
Anthony Howes
Nationality: South Africa
Certifications:
  • Measurer in Training
  • Judge In Training
  • Club Race Officer
  • Regional Race Officer
Question about displaying a red flag?

Is there anything that would prevent a boat from displaying a red flag from the start of the race until the end?

Reason:  The boat now does not need to try to raise a red flag and only has to hail "protest".

  • Would this be considered unsportsmanlike?
  • Is there a rule against this?


Created: Today 11:12

Comments

Format:
Jim Champ
Nationality: United Kingdom
I have a feeling that it has been found unsportsmanlike. However I think its probably rare for there to be a start sequence at which there are no incidents that one could raise a half credible protest for.  Does rather emphasise what a nonsense the rule is though.
Created: Today 12:00
P
Angelo Guarino
Forum Moderator
Nationality: United States
Certifications:
  • Regional Judge
Anthony let's look at the rule.   (Emphasis added)

RRS 60.2(a)
If a protest concerns an incident observed by the protestor in the racing area:
  1. If the protestor is a boat, she shall hail ‘Protest’ and, if her hull length is longer than 6 metres, conspicuously display a red flag, at the first reasonable opportunity for each. She shall display the flag until she is no longer racing.

The sentence structure is "she shall [action] ... at the first reasonable opportunity for each [incident]"

The "at ... for each" required the [action] to be done at a time that is associated with the "incident observed". 

I don't think raising the flag at the start breaks a rule  .. but IMO doing so would make any subsequent protest invalid, due to the conclusion that the act of displaying the flag was not displayed "at ... for each incident". 

If however .. there was a protest at the start, this boat is required to continue flying it for the duration of the race and subsequent protests only require a hail. For multiple incidents, the flag is displayed at the first incident. 

If there is subterfuge involved and uncovered, then they do risk those consequences.  
 
The juice doesn't seem worth the squeeze.   Just figure out a handy way to keep the flag ready to fly. 
Created: Today 12:45
Mark Townsend
Nationality: United States
Certifications:
  • International Umpire
  • International Race Officer
  • International Judge
Reply to: 22311 - Angelo Guarino
The sentence structure is "she shall [action] ... at the first reasonable opportunity for each [incident]"
Angelo, 
The sentence structure is "she shall [action] ... at the first reasonable opportunity for each [incident]"

based on your logic I would need to carry multiple red flags, one for each incident I might be involved in?
 
Created: Today 14:23
Michael Moradzadeh
Certifications:
  • Club Race Officer
This would be one of those cases where, of you have an a*hole racer that does this, maybe it's an RSS violation, but you simply add a sailing instruction that forbids the practice. Or take them aside and tell them to knock it off.  If you are the sailor contemplating doing this, you may wish to consider the meaning of "sportsmanship."
Created: Today 13:06
Jim Champ
Nationality: United Kingdom
>meaning of sportsmanship

My response would be on the lines of "anyone who thinks  a delayed protest flag should be a get-out-of-gaol-free for breaking the rules is in no position to lecture me about sportsmanship."
Created: Today 13:15
Caveat: English is not my native language
Angelo, for me "each" referes not to incidents but to the two actions "hail" and "display red flag". So a boat is obliged to do each at the respective first reasonable opportunity. 

For what it's worth I asked Google's opinion on that matter. I think it kind of backed my understanding (emphasis by Google):

"In this sentence, the word "each" refers to the two required actions: hailing "Protest" and conspicuously displaying a red flag.

Grammatical Breakdown
The phrasing is taken directly from Rule 61.1(a) [sic!] of the World Sailing Racing Rules of Sailing. The phrase "at the first reasonable opportunity for each" means:
- The boat must hail "Protest" at the first reasonable opportunity for hailing.
- The boat must display the red flag at the first reasonable opportunity for displaying the flag.

The rule recognizes that a crew might be able to do one action before the other. For example, a solo sailor can instantly shout "Protest" during a collision, but they may need to untangle lines or stabilize the boat for a few moments before they can physically reach and hoist the red flag. Under this rule, the timeline for evaluating a "reasonable opportunity" is judged independently for each action.
Created: Today 13:17
The heading of rule 60.2 is "intention to protest". So a red flag signals your intention to protest. I'm not sure what it means, if it's displayed but ther is not actual "intention" (yet?). Also what does it mean when you cross the finishing line with the red flag but no grounds for a protest?
Created: Today 13:29
You must be signed in to add a comment.
Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies. Learn more